Thank you to everyone who has watched this video and engaged with us! We have another episode that dives deeper into Taiwan's national security in relation to China and the rest of the world. Enjoy 'Now You Know' Ep.1 with Ronan Fu here: ruclips.net/video/sNviuvuuelw/видео.html
Why do you think the US is pulling out of Europe? This will be a 2 theatre war like WW2. You will have Europe v Russia, and then you will have US, Australia and Japan (plus many more) v China. And if India throws down, things will get real real quick. But then again India might just take the opportunity to liberate Tibet instead 😊.
I think it’s far more likely that the US blockades Brazil in response and begins reconquest of Latin America to put the squeeze on Eurasian access to food. The plan would be in response to Chinese and Russian aggression and European abandonment of NATO to just starve Eurasia and waive our nuclear weapons at the rest of the world if they try to stop the United States.
@colmmullins valid call, but I think it runs deeper that that. If the US let Taiwan fall, what is the message to Japan, Phillipines, and the rest of SEA. They will be thinking that they are next and the US will not help. We are at the pointy end of Thucydides Trap, and the US has the choice to make a stand or be washed away into the annuals of history. I just cannot see the US giving up hegemony without a fight.
Stupid comments keep comparing Ukraine with Taiwan, Taiwan is surrounded by water whereas Russian soldiers can just run over to Ukraine to pluck apple. So which is easier , swimming or running.
You cannot compare Ukraine forces with Taiwan. Taiwan army forces are a joke. Facts: last 20 years armed force personnel has only 3 months of training. They do not go out to train if weather is too hot like 90 degree F). If China would simple do naval blockade with their navy(300+ warships including 100 sub, 100+ destroyers, 3 carrier), Taiwan would run out of supply within 1 week. Taiwan has around 25 old American frigates build in 1960s.
Also a different socioeconomic situation compared to Ukraine. If Taiwan falls to China control, 70% of international shipping trade in the Indo-Pacific will be at risk and many nations won't tolerate that. AUS + 🇺🇸🤝+ 🇹🇼🤝+ 🇯🇵🤝+ 🇰🇷🤝🇮🇳 + 🤝🇵🇭 +🤝🇻🇳 ---> 🥾🇨🇳
@@RAYYANHERNANDEZ It's not stupid but facts. Army training just revert to 1 year training instead of 3 months at the request of US about 6 months ago. This is in the news. This is the doing of green party of Taiwan which implements stupid policy the last 8+ years. Instead of boosting fighting capabilities of our army forces, Democratic Progressive Party of Taiwan focus on gay rights and criminal rights.
In 1990s, I was asking China military people, you really think you could take back the Island of Taiwan? Their answer was no, our navy was too weak. And the Americans are guarding for Taiwan. However, there was another way to take Taiwan back, that was to spread rumours and tell the refugees in the mainland China that there were free money to be paid out (just like America and Canada, free social securities, the government will pay you to buy a new house that kind of myths) and instantly there will be 20million refugees sailing towards the Island of Taiwan and sank the island's economy. It was a joke at the time, but somehow we knew this could be true. That was what happened to Hong Kong when the Vietnamese people plus the mainlanders. Fast forward to today, Taiwan is now fairly rich, no one wants to go to war. The will to fight, against your Chinese brothers are silly. As soon as the war breaks out, everyone (every parent in Taiwan) will realise they are sending their sons and daughters to die, for the Americans', then there will be a wake up call, and the war will simply stop. Trust me on that. Only the Americans want this war to happen. Not Mainland nor island of Taiwan. There will always be some naive kids in Taiwan who did not read history. Well, that happens a lot in Hongkong too when many Hongkong chinese were waving the Union Jack and thought they are British (when the Brits call them Refugee or Aslyum seekers). Bunch of idiots who have been watching too much Hollywood.
Let us be clear, there is no taking back of Taiwan, it would be annexing Taiwan. China has never conquered Taiwan. Even the Non Chinese Manchu only loosely controlled less than 20% of the island. Japan is the only country that subdued the Taiwanese aboriginals and seized full control. Let us also be clear. Taiwanese do NOT want to be ruled by the CCP.
Exactly, no prosperous country want a war. Especially Chinese against another Chinese. There's no way this will happen ever. Some politician or extrimist might want to (from both side) but the (huge) majority of Chinese will not want to, not to mention all the Chinese descendants all over the world will speak loudly against it (the war, not on the issue of Taiwan as part of China)
IF most western militaries have learned from the Ukraine War that "SeaBaby" USVs can dominate near-shore seas and that UAV First Person drones can dominate Armour, Artillery and Troops .... then it must be a secret. This lesson has been downplayed by those who want to drive Ships, Tanks, IFVs and APCs into battle, but all will be devastated if the enemy has 10,000 SeaBaby attack drones ready to battle 400 ships and 3 million FPV flying claymore mines or RPG carrying drones. Taiwan - are you LEARNING??
Everybody in the comments is just denouncing him or calling him shameless. But can you refute any of his arguments with facts or an opposing point of view? If not then no one needs to take your comments seriously.
Let's start from claim one, he said "Xi told PLA to be ready to invade Taiwan by 2027." Can you point to any original source about it? None. Because it's fake news. No one would trust a guy if he can't even get his claim number one right.
I could be wrong but there all probably two strategies that would almost all but guarantee a defeat for China if it invades Taiwan. 1) Western Countries make a stand: If the US and other western countries stand up to Chinas invasion the odds are it will not go as China/PLA between losses and political/economic fallout. 2) If Taiwan and the allies are unable to hold on to the island they destroy anything and everything (like the Russians did to Germany in WWII) it will make it a hollow victory for China if after exhausting so much resources to get Taiwan they end up with just a empty piece of land that os covered with ruins. 🤔
I am just wondering how they are going to handle the TSMC fabs. Sure, they understand this (SMIC, etc), but how are they going to keep it going with high-yields. Could be a real problem for global semiconductors!
The last time China tried to invade Taiwan in 1949, there was no international aid. China didn't make it even 1/10th of the way across the strait before they were stopped at Kinmen Island (a Taiwanese island so close to China that you can see it from China's coast). Their biggest enemy was the water, as every second a soldier spends on the water is a second where they're a sitting duck. To reach Taiwan, Chinese troops would need to travel for over 110 miles where they are completely defenseless and unable to retreat. A very difficult task for even the most powerful and advanced army in the world, and China's army is neither of those.
Comparing Taiwan with Ukraine? So you study history to prepare for a Math test? your comment pretty much prove you only look at everything in life superficially.
Well as a Taiwanese American, technically speaking the US, Japan, Philippines, Australia would be fucked if they were to lose Taiwan to the PLA. Not only would they allow the PLA to open a new trade route in the Arctic, these countries would also be facing direct confrontation with China in the Pacific. They would also be more prone to attacks from China if the PLA feels it is under threat. These are just a few problems out of many the US and allies would face in the off chance they lose Taiwan to Communism. I think the stakes are quite high here in comparison to Ukraine, where losing Ukraine to Russians wouldn’t increase military conflict since there’s NATO in place.
@@risperidone8830 If China take control of Taiwan, it's just business as usual(just like Hong Kong). China is interest in making money not war. By the way, China is communist in name only. You are allow to own company, private jet, cars, yachts, and other stuff;Therefore they are capitalist.
@@risperidone8830 Right so china didn't just do a circumnavigation of australia? Regardless of Taiwan, everyone in the vacinity will need to face direct confrontation with China in the Pacific. Why do you think the Japanese are so keen on going to beijing now. Even the pentagon has sobered up to that fact that they need to retreat to the third island chain. Why do you think China has developed the J-36 fighter with such long range. The chinese intend to fight the americans out to the third island chain or further. Taiwan means nothing in this context.
@@risperidone8830 What is this communism I read it in a book once Name ONE country that litterally pracises communism. Its just a beat up by billionaires who dont want to pay their fair share of tax. If making them pay their fair shre of tax ,and exposes corruption which is rife in many Western countries is communism Then bring it on
I think IF China goes for Taiwan, it will take a few days or weeks to take over Taiwan without interference from coalition forces. Then, IF, the coalition forces deem Taiwan worthy of liberating after much political debate, they will have a contingency plan to retake Taiwan back. If I was the coalition forces, I would from the gecko, commit to preventing China from overtaking Taiwan. Make "them" lose more of their men trying to take it over, than say our coalition forces trying to retake it. If the coalition forces establish a strong foothold on the strait from the gecko, it'll be harder for China and may give coalition forces a huge advantage. But lets say they do take it over, and coalition forces don't get involved initially (besides providing weapons supplies). Then, Most likely the coalition contingency plan will consist of taking back the island by establishing air superiority first, coordinating with the remaining Taiwan troops to establish an entry point for coalition troops to enter from the Eastern front. The big issue I see is coalition forces not being able to distinguish friends from foes, or having interference from China with comms to establish a network of operations and coordinate a counter-attack. China may play it dirty here. Japan and Korea will, IF THEY PARTICIPATE, come from the North Eastern fronts while U.S. & Philippines (maybe if they choose to participate) will come from the mid-south eastern fronts simultaneously. This retake may be much more difficult if Russia and N.K. get involved. That'll push the S. Korean forces to revert their efforts back at their homeland due to N.K. threat and involvement, whilst trying to assist coalition forces logistically with the retake of Taiwan. (If they deem it worth participating in). China will have the advantage by air and sea from the western fronts from the beginning due to the close proximity to their homeland. They have the logistical advantage here. China's long range missiles, and anti-air weapons, will be much more effective if the coalition forces try to cut China off with a retake from the Taiwan Strait. I think Coalition forces would have more casualties if they plan a retake from the strait. That idea would be primarily to "cut" China off logistically, and assuming China already invaded Taiwan and they have troops on the ground, if the coalition forces succeed, its an easy retake. But again, High cost, high reward method there. But I think China knows this, so the best bet is a retake Taiwan from the Eastern front where the coalition forces have ships and carriers that can provide better artillery, anti-air, and ground support. The way I see it, maybe China might have a contingency plan that involves satellites and communication interference to prevent the coalition forces from establishing and executing a plan effectively. This will only delay a retake IMO tho... It will be a bloody mess if it ever happens. Hopefully no war occurs man. Lets just live in peace please. All this changes if China attacks all these asian countries simultaneously tho. But, the big advantage here is that China does not have as much fighting experience as western coalition forces do.
They Didn't even help ukraine , and you assume they would send help across the sea which is more expensive, especially to fight someone as advanced and powerful as china
@@Aaadybaoy They didn't you say? You mean Japan and South Korea? They did help Ukraine by providing financial assistance. Did you even bother looking it up lol? Japan 12 billion S.Korea 100 million Ukraine uses that money to buy weapons, supplies, whatever is needed during their wartime efforts. If you want to make a point that they didn't offer enough, that's not for me to decide. Ask them lol You say I "assumed"? I literally used conditional statements., hence the term "IF"... War time strategies are literally assumptions of what the other party will "potentially" do. China is advanced. But not experienced in war as much as some of the coalition forces.
No. You need to start thinking like the Vietnamese , not the Chinese. Every man and woman needs to bear arms and defend yourselves. The rest of the world is coming to your aid, it would be nice for you to help.
What will be the consequence If China attack Taiwan? The exact consequence is Taiwan can raise its NATIONAL FLAG, a nation by fact and act. Why? No country would wage to its own place; the fact the China would want to take Taiwan is a fact the Taiwan is an independent nation by fact and act. There is no need to be discussing whose Taiwan is, because Taiwan by fact and act is a nation with its own government and Laws with its jurisdiction that China must respect. Congratulation Taiwan for courage!!! I salute you all!!!
They need to understand that China imports and exports too much. Their main buyer is the USA and they cannot replace that. The US buys 35% of all exports in the world. The minute you lose that consumer market, your economy is screwed and in China's case, eventually you starve. The US could blockade China's ability to feed its own people, 3000 miles away from China. They would have to come out and fight but they cannot sustain their navy past the first island chain.
Taiwan is facing serious problem recruiting soldiers. Clinging hope on the US to come to the aid of Taiwan is a wishful dream. You just have to get your Taiwan president to declare independence to make it happen
Sounds like this “expert” is just another loudmouth prick who thinks he’s got the future on speed dial 😂😂😂 I don't see China invading Taiwan and I don't think they will I just don't 😂😂😂 so this was stupid analysis to a so called expert, Gordon chang 2.0 😂😂
Those neighbors who come to Taiwan aid is thinking short term, but their proximity to China is long term, any neighbors countries aiding Taiwan is stupid. Rubbish comments.
As to whether China can conquer Taiwan, even the Taiwanese political leaders like Chen Tan Sun (Mark Chen), the former Secretary General of Taiwan National Security Council had admitted that the Chinese already have the capabilities to conquer Taiwan now ! "China vs USA - empires at war"
An idiot, to destroy Taiwan's bridges, power stations, etc. do we need sleeper agents? Do you know that the PLA can easily do it with their long range fire. Still dreaming, right?
Chinese do test their weapons against live targets, such as old ships and successfully shot down their own satellite 20 years ago. You honestly think people do not do any test to see if their stuff works. They build a space station and landed on moon.
Inexperience is a factor only during the first few months of a war. Good doctrine and realistic training can do a lot to buffer it. It is not as big a factor in the case of Taiwan, where the decisive factor is Naval.
The formal government of China had to escape to Taiwan for the reds. So, formally China has no right to take back Taiwan. Meaning leave Taiwan in piece. The current governments since 1948, did not sit still. They developed their defence up till now. So, China, think first before you take any action against Taiwan. You can hurt yourselvs badly.
Resillianche yang memberikan resistanching keamanan bersama pada zoon lions wilayah pertahanan bersama adalah untuk mengendalikan illegal trollicriminales traceris zoom lions secara kolaborasi. Potensi kedepannya untuk mengatasi populasi meningkatnya ilegal iads
@ Yan.........: Working for Raytheon in the US, says it all. Hey, Tony Hu, " intuition " fee for this rubbish presentation from American M. Complex, or CIA, or NED ??
@James-e1h8l No, US usually sold taiwan outdated weapons. US govenment investigated raysheon and asked they refund around 2 billion dollars, which they overcharged. Tony Hu was the sale manager of this deal
Superb factual analysis which can be easily digested by someone who knows more than anyone concerning Taiwan's defense responses and the enemies capabilities. Additionally, the gentleman's style is quite entertaining....love this show, love the channel ❤!
The ROC and PRC are two separate entities. PRC was formed in 1949. The ROC was officially recreated in 1951. October 1, 1949, at 3:00 pm in Tienanmen Square the formation of the Central People's Government under the leadership of the CCP, the government of the new state, was officially proclaimed. Mao declared victory to the people stating “The poor peasants have conquered the country; the poor peasants should now sit on the country.” The PRC and a new nation was formed, The CCP created the constitution, and it did not even contain Taiwan. lol In April 28, 1952 Article 10 of the Taipei Peace Treaty clearly declares the sovereignty of the ROC “nationals of the Republic of China shall be deemed to include all the inhabitants and former inhabitants of Taiwan (Formosa) and Penghu (the Pescadores).” Therefore the Taipei Peace Treaty declares the ROC to be All inhabitants of Taiwan but no mention of China or PRC.
@ResearchFirst-z7j lol, do you know what are you talking about? Do you know what is history and what is legacy? BTW, pls check the constitution of PRC. Don't try to spread misleading information here. Above that, does Taiwanese knows that ROC is "recreated" in 1952? You refer to Taipei peace treaty, that is treaty between ROC and Japan. Doesn't define the territory of ROC. I don't know you lie on this. The territory definition is in ROC constitution, which includes both the Chinese mainland and Taiwan. Please do more work, before you spread these nonsense words.
@@Qiushishuo Hang on Einstein, I just gave you evidence to prove that the ROC and PRC are two different entities. There are no internationally recognised treaties, policies or UN resolutions that state that Taiwan is part of China, So prove me wrong. The Taipei Peace Treaty clearly declares the sovereignty of the ROC “nationals of the Republic of China shall be deemed to include all the inhabitants and former inhabitants of Taiwan (Formosa) and Penghu (the Pescadores)." And dont give me that constitution garbage. When the ROC wrote their constitution in 1946 Taiwan belonged to Japan and therefore means nothing. There are no internationally recognised treaties, policies or UN resolutions that state that Taiwan is part of China, and you cannot prove otherwise.
@ResearchFirst-z7j lol, you are so funny. As a defeated criminal in WWII, there is no right for Japan to hold Taiwan after Japan formally surrendered. Your claim cannot even be supported by Japanese government. I don't why do you insist these lies.
@@ResearchFirst-z7j What he meant was that DPP(Democratic Progressive Party of Taiwan) is continuous putting lies on RUclips and other American media. DPP or the current ruling party of Taiwan is notorious for deceiving Taiwanese people. Yes, I am from Taiwan.
The question is whether US has the incentive to defend Taiwan. The Ukraine war reveals the true Russia capabilities and if anything US is no longer worried about Russia anymore. China is the true strategic threat. Among various ways of preventing the threat, a war is an option, the earlier it breaks out the bigger advantage US has. China invading Taiwan provides the opportunity, isn’t it?
27 years as US Air Force officer including Missile combat Crew Commander, HQ Pacific Air Forces, and Pacific Area War Planner. 7 Years as US Dept of Defense Senior Official including as Senior Director for China/Taiwan/Mongolia in the Office of the Secretary of Defense, Pentagon and Dep Chief of Security Assistance Office in Taiwan.
The total value of exports to China reaching approximately $101 billion in 2023; making China the largest export destination for Taiwan despite a slight decrease in recent years. So just a ban on all Taiwan imports would do, no boots on ground needed. Dominant product: Integrated circuits (ICs) are the main export from Taiwan to China, with a significant portion coming from companies like TSMC (Taiwan Semiconductor Manufacturing Company). Decreasing trend: While still substantial, Taiwan's exports to China have been declining slightly in recent years due to factors like geopolitical tensions and a shift towards diversifying export markets. Other major exports: Aside from ICs, Taiwan also exports broadcasting equipment and office machine parts to China.
@ROC Gov't: Technically, if done properly, the ROC can win against the PRC militarily, just as did Sparta and it's allies against the Persians. Many people do not know that. Personally, I hope the Chinese people can coexist peacefully, and not fight each other, but that is up to the Chinese (PRC gov't/ROC gov't) on both sides of the TaiWan/China Strait. Most of the wars China has fought in have been civil wars throughout the ages, including the ongoing civil war between the ROC and PRC entities... Very unfortunate.
I hope you are right and being has China up to now has never invaded another country with planes and tanks. There is hope And hope that Taiwan wont be the first.But realistcally what value is a small island such as Taiwan to PRC ?any way Even with American help they would lose, as it is far away from the US.And aircraft carriers are so WW2. Ukraine is a typical example It was suicide to take on Russia on her own door step Britain and the Falklands was the exception But i dont think Argentina was enthusiastic for the Malvinas and never planned it very well
Taiwan needs to ASAP get serious about a robust citizen defense force, 15 million AKs', yes, THAT MANY!, and plenty ammo ... but I doubt they will..SAD!
📙3. THE GOSPEL OF THE WORD OF ALMIGHTY GOD "the last age is the Age of Kingdom or Word brought by Christ to purify man" Only Those Who Have Experienced God's Work Truly Believe in God Almighty God Says If PEOPLE STAY in the AGE of GRACE, THEN they will NEVER be FREE from their EVIL DISPOSITIONS, much less KNOW the NATURAL DISPOSITIONS of GOD. IF PEOPLE always LIVE in the AFFORDABILITY of GRACE but DO NOT HAVE the WAY of LIFE that ALLOWS them to KNOW GOD and GIVE--SATISFACTION to GOD, then they will NEVER TRULY OBTAIN Him EVEN THOUGH they BELIEVE in Him. WHAT a pitiful form of BELIEF that is. When you FINISH READING this BOOK, when you EXPERIENCE every STEP of the WORK of GOD INCARNATION in the AGE of the KINGDOM, you will FEEL that the HOPE of many PEOPLE has FINALLY BEEN FULFILLED. 🌷🙏🔴 You will FEEL that NOW you have TRULY SEEN GOD face to face; NOW you have STANDED on GOD'S FACE, HEARD GOD'S PERSONAL SPEECH, APPRECIATED the WISDOM of GOD'S WORK and TRULY FELT how TRUE and POWERFUL GOD is. You will FEEL that you have ACHIEVED MANY THINGS that PEOPLE in the PAST TIMES HAVE NEVER SEEN or CLAIMED. 🌷🙏🌷🙏 At this TIME, you will CLEARLY SEE WHAT BELIEVING in GOD, and WHAT FOLLOWING the HEART of GOD. 🌷🙏🔥 PLEASE NOTE, IF YOU HOLD on to the VIEWS of the PAST, and WILL NOT ACCEPT or REJECT the TRUTH of the SECOND INCARNATION--MAN of GOD, THEN you WILL REMAIN TONGUELESS and NOTHING ACQUIRED, and in the END--LASTLY WILL SIN of DEFENDING GOD. Those who FOLLOW the TRUTH and SUBMIT to the WORK of GOD WILL COME UNDER the NAME of the SECOND INCARNATION--MAN GOD---the POWERFUL--over--ALL. 🙏🌷 They WILL RECEIVE PERSONAL GUIDANCE from GOD, and WILL ACHIEVE greater and HIGHER TRUTH and will RECEIVE TRUE human LIFE. 🙏 They WILL SEE a VISION that PEOPLE HAVE NEVER SEEN BEFORE: "And I turned to see a voice speaking unto Me. And when I turned I saw seven golden candlesticks: And in the midst of the candlesticks there was one like a son of man, clothed with a garment down to the feet, and having his breast girded with a golden girdle. And his head and his hair were white like wool, like snow; and his eyes were like a flame of fire; And his feet were like polished brass, as refined in an iron furnace; and his voice was likesplash a lot of water. And in his right hand were seven stars: and out of his mouth went a sharp two-edged sword: and his face was like the sun shining brightly." (Revelation 1:12-16). 🔥🙏 This VISION is the EXPRESSION of GOD'S WHOLE DISPOSITION, and such an EXPRESSION of His entire disposition is also an EXPRESSION of GOD'S WORK when He became MAN during this TIME. In the flood of punishments and judgments, the SON of MAN appreciates His NATURAL DISPOSITION by UTTERING WORDS, allowing all who receive His PUNISHMENT and JUDGMENT to SEE the TRUE FACE of the SON of MAN, a FACE already FAITHFUL DESCRIPTION of the face of the SON of MAN as SEEN by JOHN.🔥 (Of course, all of this will not be seen by those who do not accept God's work in the Age of Kingdom.) The TRUE FACE of the CANNOT be FULLY expressed CLEARLY USING MAN'S WORDS, and thus GOD USES the REVEALING of His NATUREDISPOSITION to SHOW His TRUE FACE to PEOPLE. Which means that EVERYONE WHO EXPERIENCES the NATURAL DISPOSITION of the SON of MAN has SEEN the REAL FACE of the SON of MAN, because GOD is too GREAT and CANNOT be COMPLETELY EXPRESSED CLEARLY USING human words. 🔴 Once man has experienced every step of God's work in the AGE OF THE KINGDOM, then he will KNOW the TRUE MEANING of JOHN'S words when he SPOKE OF THE SON OF MAN IN THE MIDST of the candlesticks: "And his head and his hair are white aswool white as snow; and his eyes were like a flame of fire; And his feet were like polished brass, as refined in an iron furnace; and his voice is like the rushing of many waters. And in his right hand are seven stars: and out of his mouth goeth a sharp two-edged sword: and his face is like the sun shining brightly." 🔥🙏🔥 AT THAT TIME, YOU WILL KNOW UNMIXED- This COMMON FLESH will be doubted SPEAKING so MANY WORDS is REALLY the SECOND INCARNATION--the MAN of GOD.🙏 And you will REALLY FEEL HOW BLESSED you are, and FEEL that YOURSELF is the BLESSED.🌷 Won't you be READY to RECEIVE this GRACE? The FIRST PART of this BOOK is the WORDS of the SPIRIT to the CHURCHES. 🙏 These WORDS REPRESENT the TRANSITION from the END of the AGE of GRACE to the BEGINNING of the KINGDOM AGE, and these are the PUBLIC WITNESSES of the SPIRIT to the CHURCHES concerning the SON OF MAN. 🙏🔴 These are also the FULFILLMENTS of the WORDS in the BOOK of REVELATION that "He who has an ear, let him listen to what the Spirit says to the churches." This is the WORK GOD BEGAN in the KINGDOM AGE. The SECOND PART of this BOOK is the PERSONAL WORDS SPOKE by the SON of MAN after He OFFICIALLY REVEALED Himself.🙏 It contains a rich content of many TYPES of UTTERANCES and WORDS such as PROPHECY, the REVELATION of MYSTERIES, and the WAY OF LIFE. There are PROPHECIES for the FUTURE of the KINGDOM, REVELATIONS of the MYSTERIES of GOD'S GOVERNMENT PLAN, ANALYSIS of HUMAN NATURE, SERMONS and WARNINGS, STRICT JUDGMENTS, SINCERE words of COMFORT, CONVERSATIONS on LIFE, ADMISSION CONVERSATION, and more. 🔴🙏 In other words, what God has, what He is, and GOD'S DISPOSITION are ALL SHOWN in His ACTIONS and WORDS. of COURSE, when GOD BECAME FLESH at this TIME, His JOB was to DECLARE His DISPOSITION, MAINLY through PUNISHMENT and JUDGMENT. Using this as a FOUNDATION, He BRINGS MORE TRUTH to MAN, shows more methods of practice, and thus ACHIEVES His PURPOSE of SUBJECTING man and SAVING MAN from His EVIL DISPOSITION. This is what is BEHIND God's WORK in the Kingdom Age. 🙏🔴 Do you WANT to ENTER the NEW AGE? Do YOU WANT to REMOVE BAD DISPOSITIONS from YOURSELF? Do you want to ATTAIN a HIGHER REALITY? Do YOU WANT to SEE the REAL FACE of thr SON of MAN? Do YOU WANT to LIVE a LIFE of USEFULNESS? Do0 YOU WANT to be MADE PERFECT by GOD? If so, HOW will you WELCOME JESUS' RETURN? 🙏 ⬇️ The recorded prophecy is below! ⬇️ The fulfillment of Juan's VISION (Rev. 1:12-16 "A Vision of Christ") "And I turned to see a voice speaking unto Me. And when I turned I saw seven golden candlesticks: And in the midst of the candlesticks there was one like a son of man, clothed with a garment down to the feet, and having his breast girded with a golden girdle. And his head and his hair were white like wool, like snow; and his eyes were like a flame of fire; And his feet were like polished brass, as refined in an iron furnace; and his voice was likesplash a lot of water. And in his right hand were seven stars: and out of his mouth went a sharp two-edged sword: and his face was like the sun shining brightly." (Rev. 1:12-16). ⬇️ ↪️(Note: Almighty God said, They WILL SEE a VISION that PEOPLE HAVE NEVER SEEN BEFORE: "And I turned to see a voice speaking unto Me. And when I turned I saw seven golden candlesticks: And in the midst of the candlesticks there was one like a son of man, clothed with a garment down to the feet, and having his breast girded with a golden girdle. And his head and his hair were white like wool, like snow; and his eyes were like a flame of fire; And his feet were like polished brass, as refined in an iron furnace; and his voice was likesplash a lot of water. And in his right hand were seven stars: and out of his mouth went a sharp two-edged sword: and his face was like the sun shining brightly." (Revelation 1:12-16). This VISION is the EXPRESSION of GOD'S WHOLE DISPOSITION, and such an EXPRESSION of His entire disposition is also an EXPRESSION of GOD'S WORK when He became MAN during this TIME.) ⬇️ (Rev. 2:7,11,27,29, and 3:6,13 The Letter to the Churches) "He who has an ear, let him listen to what the Spirit says to the churches." ⬇️ ↪️(Note: Almighty God said, These are also the FULFILLMENTS of the WORDS in the BOOK of REVELATION that "He who has an..
This commentator has a green mouth, a green heart, a green brain, and everything in him is green, just like the green metal cabinet beside him, actually not fresh green but shitty green. Hahaha.
China under the CCP mismanagement of it's economy is one for Taiwan's best attributes for it's defense. The real estate collapse las an empty apartment for every person, man woman and child in that country. All the banks are insolvent. Every "stimulus" by the CCP is met by a brief stock market rally followed by and further decline deeper that before. The economy is collapsing. Youth unemployment is at least 59%. The attitude of hopelessness among the youth is charactered by the phrase of ;lie flat' do as little as possible to 'let it die'.
Why would China make such a sick effort just for a frivolous Taiwan? What would they do with it? Their manufacturing sector is in trouble, and they logically should be thinking more about that…
Exactly, Europe was talking about politics but did little to help Ukraine over time. Time is a advantage to a big aggressor. Massively building quality sea and air drones is the cheapest option. Harpoons and Patriots are a better bet but are more costly
@@cfoldesh Not invasion, just recovering lost territory, the taiwanese and green birds can go live in trump's house or in Belize Guatemala Haiti Marshall Islands Palau Paraguay Saint Kitts and Nevis Saint Lucia Saint Vincent and the Grenadines Eswatini Tuvalu Vatican City
@@Qiushishuo Taiwan was not even added to the PRC constitution until 1978? The 1978 PRC Constitution was the first Constitution in the PRC to touch explicitly on the political status of Taiwan. It said that "Taiwan is part of China" and said that the PRC "must liberate Taiwan, and finish the great task of reunifying the motherland". However, in 1979, the PRC dropped the liberation stance and opted for peaceful reunification instead. The 1982 Constitution mentioned that "Taiwan is a sacred part of the territory of the People's Republic of China" instead of just "China". The fact is the war was never over Taiwan and during the civil war the island legally belonged to Japan not China. Once Mao died the PRC constitution was amended to state that Taiwan was part of China,
If so, tell the Taiwanese Goverment to declare Independence tomorrow, otherwise all you are saying is nonsense. Btw, life must be difficult not being a US defense officer anymore, coming here talking nonsnese getting few extra bucks 😂
Irrespective of whether Taiwan is considered a country or not does not automatically cede the sovereignty to China. The fact is that there are no internationally recognized treaties, policies or UN resolutions that state that Taiwan is part of China. In fact, Taiwan was not even included into the PRC constitution until 1978.
@@ResearchFirst-z7j Taiwan is a part of China for a lot of reasons, but I'll give you 3. Number 1: Taiwan and Mainland China are the Inheritance of Qing Dynasty, whether Communists or Non-communists run Mainland China and Taiwan, it's a part of China(whether it's communist or not). Number 2: Taiwan is not a name of the country, but a name of the place. Republic of China is the name of Taiwan, and there is the word "China" in it. So it's part of China, or it's China. The problem of Taiwan and Mainland China is not about whether Taiwan is a part of China( because it is), but rather who runs the whole China(Mainland China + Taiwan). The Republic of China lost in the Civil War, they should merge with Mainland China(ruled by the Communists). Number 3: People who are living in Taiwan all come from Mainland China, and they are about 20 millions of them, then WTH the land of All Chinese should be decided by only 20 millions Chinese people in Taiwan but not 1.4 billion Chinese in Mainland China? Taiwan or Mainland China are the lands of current Chinese's ancestors and all Chinese(regardless they are living in Mainland China, Hong Kong, Macau, Taiwan) should have the say and right to say in it, not just a few 20 millions people in Taiwan. No internally treaties recognize Taiwan is a part of China? Do Chinese people in Mainland China need a treaty to claim their homeland of their ancestors? You do know International Treaties are for the benefits of the Winners of WW2, right? And since China was not USA, USSR, Britan, and they were conquered by the Imperial Japanese, who cares about their territorial integrity? But that does not mean Taiwan is not them. The problem with Taiwan nowadays is Taiwanese Politicians trying to get votes by creating dramas to push normal citizens to unnecessary wars with their blood brothers and sisters. That's all. It's not about democracy, just pure greed of power by the politicians.
@@brianawhite1796 That is a lovely Anglo Saxon name Brian White. How funny. Lol The fact is that there are no internationally recognized treaties, policies or UN resolutions that state that Taiwan is part of China and you are going to have to try much harder to prove otherwise. ha ha ha 1: You claim that China is the inheritance of the Manchurian Qing Dynasty who were not even Chinese. Lol What a joke. Please show me where the Manchurians transferred their conquered lands to the PRC. Prove it 2: In terms of Taiwan, the Manchurians never conquered Taiwan and only loosely controlled less than 20% of Taiwan. therefore there was nothing to inherit. LOL The Qing annexed Taiwan in 1683 but only controlled the western plains, with their authority limited to the “Niu line,” a boundary separating the lowlands from the mountainous interior. Beyond this line, Indigenous peoples maintained control over most of the island. While the Qing made small expansions beyond the Niu line, their reach remained minimal. Han and Hakka settlers frequently clashed over land and resources, fueled by rivalries from Fujian. Limited resources and weak administration further reduced Qing control. Japan was the first country to subdue the Taiwanese aboriginals and seize control of Taiwan. Your funny. lol 3: The Republic of China is not China and has not been since 1971. The ROC and PRC are two separate entities. PRC was formed in 1949. The ROC was officially recreated in 1951. October 1, 1949, at 3:00 pm in Tienanmen Square the formation of the Central People's Government under the leadership of the CCP, the government of the new state, was officially proclaimed. Mao declared victory to the people stating “The poor peasants have conquered the country; the poor peasants should now sit on the country.” The PRC and a new nation was formed, The CCP created the constitution, and it did not even contain Taiwan. lol In April 28, 1952 Article 10 of the Taipei Peace Treaty clearly declares the sovereignty of the ROC “nationals of the Republic of China shall be deemed to include all the inhabitants and former inhabitants of Taiwan (Formosa) and Penghu (the Pescadores).” Therefore the Taipei Peace Treaty declares the ROC to be All inhabitants of Taiwan but no mention of China or PRC. Tell me why there is a country called Guinea, another called Papua New Guinea, another called Guinea Bissau and another called Equatorial Guinea????? Are they all the same country?? I can't stop laughing. lol 4: In terms of the civil war. During the civil war Taiwan was part of Japan. The civil war was never over Taiwan. In fact, Taiwan was not even added to the PRC constitution until 1978? This is hilarious. The 1978 PRC Constitution was the first Constitution in the PRC to touch explicitly on the political status of Taiwan. It said that "Taiwan is part of China" and said that the PRC "must liberate Taiwan, and finish the great task of reunifying the motherland". However, in 1979, the PRC dropped the liberation stance and opted for peaceful reunification instead. The 1982 Constitution mentioned that "Taiwan is a sacred part of the territory of the People's Republic of China" instead of just "China". The fact is the war was never over Taiwan and during the civil war the island legally belonged to Japan not China. Once Mao died the PRC constitution was amended to state that Taiwan was part of China, Sorry I am still laughing. lol 5: Yes, the PRC will need a treaty to claim Taiwan as it has never been controlled by the PRC or China. As I told you there are no internationally recognized treaties, policies, agreements or UN resolutions that declare that Taiwan is part of China and you cannot prove otherwise. Lol When Japan relinquished its sovereignty of Taiwan with The Treaty of San Francisco after the ROC invaded the Japanese island, China was not even invited. The treaty was signed by 49 nations including the Soviet Union but the CCP were NOT present. I am crying with laughter. 6: Yes, I agree with you, its ALL about greed and power of the CCP. Historically the CCP recognized Formosan independence. In 1936, when the Republic of China (ROC) was China’s government and Taiwan (Formosa) was a Japanese colony, Chairman Mao Zedong offered support to Korea and Formosa if their peoples wished to gain independence from Japan. Mao’s internationalist position suggested that 1) both Korea and Formosa have a right to independence, and 2) this is based on the right to self-determination. Mao did not claim that Taiwan has been an integral part of China for centuries, as insisted by the Chinese government today. Interview with Mao in 1936 An interview sourced from the Marxist Archive demonstrates this. Interviewer EDGAR SNOW: “Is it the immediate task of the Chinese people to regain all the territories lost to Japan, or only to drive Japan from North China, and all Chinese territory above the Great Wall? “ MAO: “It is the immediate task of China to regain all our lost territories, not merely to defend our sovereignty below the Great Wall. This means that Manchuria must be regained. We do not, however, include Korea, formerly a Chinese colony, but when we have re-established the independence of the lost territories of China, and if the Koreans wish to break away from the chains of Japanese imperialism, we will extend them our enthusiastic help in their struggle for independence. The same thing applies to Formosa.” Source: Marxists Internet Archive You are so funny and thank you for the laughter. if you want to learn more truths about Taiwan please feel free to let me know. lol Have a great day.
Australia should mind its own business and keep out of the area, God knows why we’re sending naval vessels into Taiwan straits , and south China Sea. we should mind our own business.
Thank you to everyone who has watched this video and engaged with us! We have another episode that dives deeper into Taiwan's national security in relation to China and the rest of the world. Enjoy 'Now You Know' Ep.1 with Ronan Fu here: ruclips.net/video/sNviuvuuelw/видео.html
Taiwan is no nation, so the so called national security is a false proposition
Lol this guy is a joke, you have run Taiwan poorly and now the working class is suffering
Just found this channel - nice job. enjoyed the video.
@@TaiwanPlusDocs how to joint Taiwan military.
@@TaiwanPlusDocs I'm Filipino. I'm willing to join Taiwan military
All you need to know about his analysis, he’s counting on all the countries he mentioned to come to taiwans aid.
Japan, India, Vietnam, and Australia all compete with China.
Has he got any other option?
Of course, china only bully the small countries around it. It never stand up against Russia that has taken a large portion of china .
I like how he thinks 😊
Ha ha ha
Europe didn't come to defend Ukraine why would it go around the world to defend Taiwan.
Europe has given over $100B euros. US aid has clearly been enough.
They will, but they will talk about it first
No one expects EU to be relevant in anything.
False, 10th group special forces are famously inside Ukraine
@@bernardakoito😂
I think this analysis incorrectly assumes the US will come to Taiwan's aid.
Why do you think the US is pulling out of Europe? This will be a 2 theatre war like WW2. You will have Europe v Russia, and then you will have US, Australia and Japan (plus many more) v China. And if India throws down, things will get real real quick. But then again India might just take the opportunity to liberate Tibet instead 😊.
But he did layout a logical reason for his assumption.
TSMC
I think it’s far more likely that the US blockades Brazil in response and begins reconquest of Latin America to put the squeeze on Eurasian access to food. The plan would be in response to Chinese and Russian aggression and European abandonment of NATO to just starve Eurasia and waive our nuclear weapons at the rest of the world if they try to stop the United States.
@colmmullins valid call, but I think it runs deeper that that. If the US let Taiwan fall, what is the message to Japan, Phillipines, and the rest of SEA. They will be thinking that they are next and the US will not help. We are at the pointy end of Thucydides Trap, and the US has the choice to make a stand or be washed away into the annuals of history. I just cannot see the US giving up hegemony without a fight.
A war between "made in china" and MADE IN USA 😂😂😂😂😂😂
This guy is Gordon Chang's cousin
Hahaha another fake China expert
They sound like cousins, but seem to take opposite positions. Gordon sees China as a big threat, whereas Tony thinks Taiwan has some cards to play.
@@chessgeek10707you mean rely on other countries (with no defense pacts) to come to your aid? That's the card he's playing? 😂🤣
Let's wonder where he was hiding when Taiwan went back to China.
@@TingMo-n4ithere are many real china experts like Zhang zhao zhong, etc. 😂
Stupid comments keep comparing Ukraine with Taiwan, Taiwan is surrounded by water whereas Russian soldiers can just run over to Ukraine to pluck apple. So which is easier , swimming or running.
You cannot compare Ukraine forces with Taiwan. Taiwan army forces are a joke. Facts: last 20 years armed force personnel has only 3 months of training. They do not go out to train if weather is too hot like 90 degree F). If China would simple do naval blockade with their navy(300+ warships including 100 sub, 100+ destroyers, 3 carrier), Taiwan would run out of supply within 1 week. Taiwan has around 25 old American frigates build in 1960s.
How about China impose a blockage like what US did to Cuba during the Cuban Missile Crisis ????
Did you think about this, kid ?
Also a different socioeconomic situation compared to Ukraine. If Taiwan falls to China control, 70% of international shipping trade in the Indo-Pacific will be at risk and many nations won't tolerate that.
AUS + 🇺🇸🤝+ 🇹🇼🤝+ 🇯🇵🤝+ 🇰🇷🤝🇮🇳 + 🤝🇵🇭 +🤝🇻🇳 ---> 🥾🇨🇳
@@William-d9zSTUPID!!!😂
@@RAYYANHERNANDEZ It's not stupid but facts. Army training just revert to 1 year training instead of 3 months at the request of US about 6 months ago. This is in the news. This is the doing of green party of Taiwan which implements stupid policy the last 8+ years. Instead of boosting fighting capabilities of our army forces, Democratic Progressive Party of Taiwan focus on gay rights and criminal rights.
Who is this guy? He must be joking. If Taiwan is so confidence why not declare Independent and invite US military to set up base. Go on FAFO.
I agree invading Tiawan is a bad idea. I say let's all just forget the whole thing.
Exactly, as if the Chinese will back down just because something is challenging!
In 1990s, I was asking China military people, you really think you could take back the Island of Taiwan? Their answer was no, our navy was too weak. And the Americans are guarding for Taiwan.
However, there was another way to take Taiwan back, that was to spread rumours and tell the refugees in the mainland China that there were free money to be paid out (just like America and Canada, free social securities, the government will pay you to buy a new house that kind of myths) and instantly there will be 20million refugees sailing towards the Island of Taiwan and sank the island's economy.
It was a joke at the time, but somehow we knew this could be true. That was what happened to Hong Kong when the Vietnamese people plus the mainlanders.
Fast forward to today, Taiwan is now fairly rich, no one wants to go to war. The will to fight, against your Chinese brothers are silly. As soon as the war breaks out, everyone (every parent in Taiwan) will realise they are sending their sons and daughters to die, for the Americans', then there will be a wake up call, and the war will simply stop.
Trust me on that. Only the Americans want this war to happen. Not Mainland nor island of Taiwan. There will always be some naive kids in Taiwan who did not read history. Well, that happens a lot in Hongkong too when many Hongkong chinese were waving the Union Jack and thought they are British (when the Brits call them Refugee or Aslyum seekers). Bunch of idiots who have been watching too much Hollywood.
Let us be clear, there is no taking back of Taiwan, it would be annexing Taiwan.
China has never conquered Taiwan. Even the Non Chinese Manchu only loosely controlled less than 20% of the island.
Japan is the only country that subdued the Taiwanese aboriginals and seized full control.
Let us also be clear. Taiwanese do NOT want to be ruled by the CCP.
Exactly, no prosperous country want a war. Especially Chinese against another Chinese. There's no way this will happen ever. Some politician or extrimist might want to (from both side) but the (huge) majority of Chinese will not want to, not to mention all the Chinese descendants all over the world will speak loudly against it (the war, not on the issue of Taiwan as part of China)
If the mainland doesn't want war, there is no war.
They who don't want war won't invade.
I guess Taiwan should be recognized as country 🇵🇭❤️🇹🇼
I'm pilipino. I support Taiwan for independent country
If you have to tell the world how ready you are, you probably are not ready when the hammer falls
Sorry buddy nobody's gonna save you
IF most western militaries have learned from the Ukraine War that "SeaBaby" USVs can dominate near-shore seas and that UAV First Person drones can dominate Armour, Artillery and Troops .... then it must be a secret. This lesson has been downplayed by those who want to drive Ships, Tanks, IFVs and APCs into battle, but all will be devastated if the enemy has 10,000 SeaBaby attack drones ready to battle 400 ships and 3 million FPV flying claymore mines or RPG carrying drones. Taiwan - are you LEARNING??
Everybody in the comments is just denouncing him or calling him shameless. But can you refute any of his arguments with facts or an opposing point of view? If not then no one needs to take your comments seriously.
Let's start from claim one, he said "Xi told PLA to be ready to invade Taiwan by 2027." Can you point to any original source about it? None. Because it's fake news.
No one would trust a guy if he can't even get his claim number one right.
🤣🤣🤣 USA, EU, NATO, G7, Aukus, 5 Eyes and QUAD 🤡 can't stop Small Chinese Huawei from Thriving Needs to say more? 🤣🤣🤣
Bots doing their job.
How can you believe a guy who can't even get his first claim right and factual.
Cos his opinions are so dumb it doesn't warrant a dignified response...geddit ?
I could be wrong but there all probably two strategies that would almost all but guarantee a defeat for China if it invades Taiwan.
1) Western Countries make a stand: If the US and other western countries stand up to Chinas invasion the odds are it will not go as China/PLA between losses and political/economic fallout.
2) If Taiwan and the allies are unable to hold on to the island they destroy anything and everything (like the Russians did to Germany in WWII) it will make it a hollow victory for China if after exhausting so much resources to get Taiwan they end up with just a empty piece of land that os covered with ruins. 🤔
Exactly why I don't even get why china wants to invade Taiwan. Unless to feed ego.
Taiwan shines on the International Theater as a sovereign and strong democratic nation!
Such clarity and so well comunicated. Thankyou
I am just wondering how they are going to handle the TSMC fabs. Sure, they understand this (SMIC, etc), but how are they going to keep it going with high-yields. Could be a real problem for global semiconductors!
i agree sir south china sea not belong to china alone west phil. sea is ours
NEVER!!!!!!
The last time China tried to invade Taiwan in 1949, there was no international aid. China didn't make it even 1/10th of the way across the strait before they were stopped at Kinmen Island (a Taiwanese island so close to China that you can see it from China's coast). Their biggest enemy was the water, as every second a soldier spends on the water is a second where they're a sitting duck. To reach Taiwan, Chinese troops would need to travel for over 110 miles where they are completely defenseless and unable to retreat. A very difficult task for even the most powerful and advanced army in the world, and China's army is neither of those.
He can go to Ukraine to advise Zelensky on how to get US and Europe plus Taiwan help 😂😂😂
😂
Comparing Taiwan with Ukraine? So you study history to prepare for a Math test? your comment pretty much prove you only look at everything in life superficially.
Taiwan must assume they must deal with China for at least sixty days before any outside help arrives.
US seems more interested in the Pacific than Europe. Hopefully Trump doesnt throw Taiwan under the bus like he did with Zelensky.
Well as a Taiwanese American, technically speaking the US, Japan, Philippines, Australia would be fucked if they were to lose Taiwan to the PLA. Not only would they allow the PLA to open a new trade route in the Arctic, these countries would also be facing direct confrontation with China in the Pacific. They would also be more prone to attacks from China if the PLA feels it is under threat. These are just a few problems out of many the US and allies would face in the off chance they lose Taiwan to Communism. I think the stakes are quite high here in comparison to Ukraine, where losing Ukraine to Russians wouldn’t increase military conflict since there’s NATO in place.
@@risperidone8830 If China take control of Taiwan, it's just business as usual(just like Hong Kong). China is interest in making money not war. By the way, China is communist in name only. You are allow to own company, private jet, cars, yachts, and other stuff;Therefore they are capitalist.
@@risperidone8830 Right so china didn't just do a circumnavigation of australia? Regardless of Taiwan, everyone in the vacinity will need to face direct confrontation with China in the Pacific. Why do you think the Japanese are so keen on going to beijing now. Even the pentagon has sobered up to that fact that they need to retreat to the third island chain. Why do you think China has developed the J-36 fighter with such long range. The chinese intend to fight the americans out to the third island chain or further. Taiwan means nothing in this context.
@@risperidone8830 What is this communism I read it in a book once Name ONE country that litterally pracises communism. Its just a beat up by billionaires who dont want to pay their fair share of tax. If making them pay their fair shre of tax ,and exposes corruption which is rife in many Western countries is communism Then bring it on
With short term goals more important than long term strategic goals, most likely.
China’s 5th element is active and well established in Singapore as well.
This is Taiwan Plus. 😂 They will tell you anything.
Then why China cant attack😂?
So will the People's Daily, wumao!
@@genoatamayo5630 Who told you China wants to attack? 😂😂
I think IF China goes for Taiwan, it will take a few days or weeks to take over Taiwan without interference from coalition forces.
Then, IF, the coalition forces deem Taiwan worthy of liberating after much political debate, they will have a contingency plan to retake Taiwan back.
If I was the coalition forces, I would from the gecko, commit to preventing China from overtaking Taiwan. Make "them" lose more of their men trying to take it over, than say our coalition forces trying to retake it. If the coalition forces establish a strong foothold on the strait from the gecko, it'll be harder for China and may give coalition forces a huge advantage.
But lets say they do take it over, and coalition forces don't get involved initially (besides providing weapons supplies).
Then,
Most likely the coalition contingency plan will consist of taking back the island by establishing air superiority first, coordinating with the remaining Taiwan troops to establish an entry point for coalition troops to enter from the Eastern front. The big issue I see is coalition forces not being able to distinguish friends from foes, or having interference from China with comms to establish a network of operations and coordinate a counter-attack. China may play it dirty here.
Japan and Korea will, IF THEY PARTICIPATE, come from the North Eastern fronts while U.S. & Philippines (maybe if they choose to participate) will come from the mid-south eastern fronts simultaneously.
This retake may be much more difficult if Russia and N.K. get involved.
That'll push the S. Korean forces to revert their efforts back at their homeland due to N.K. threat and involvement, whilst trying to assist coalition forces logistically with the retake of Taiwan.
(If they deem it worth participating in).
China will have the advantage by air and sea from the western fronts from the beginning due to the close proximity to their homeland. They have the logistical advantage here.
China's long range missiles, and anti-air weapons, will be much more effective if the coalition forces try to cut China off with a retake from the Taiwan Strait.
I think Coalition forces would have more casualties if they plan a retake from the strait. That idea would be primarily to "cut" China off logistically, and assuming China already invaded Taiwan and they have troops on the ground, if the coalition forces succeed, its an easy retake. But again, High cost, high reward method there.
But I think China knows this, so the best bet is a retake Taiwan from the Eastern front where the coalition forces have ships and carriers that can provide better artillery, anti-air, and ground support.
The way I see it, maybe China might have a contingency plan that involves satellites and communication interference to prevent the coalition forces from establishing and executing a plan effectively. This will only delay a retake IMO tho...
It will be a bloody mess if it ever happens. Hopefully no war occurs man. Lets just live in peace please.
All this changes if China attacks all these asian countries simultaneously tho. But, the big advantage here is that China does not have as much fighting experience as western coalition forces do.
They Didn't even help ukraine , and you assume they would send help across the sea which is more expensive, especially to fight someone as advanced and powerful as china
@@Aaadybaoy They didn't you say? You mean Japan and South Korea? They did help Ukraine by providing financial assistance. Did you even bother looking it up lol?
Japan 12 billion
S.Korea 100 million
Ukraine uses that money to buy weapons, supplies, whatever is needed during their wartime efforts. If you want to make a point that they didn't offer enough, that's not for me to decide. Ask them lol
You say I "assumed"? I literally used conditional statements., hence the term "IF"...
War time strategies are literally assumptions of what the other party will "potentially" do.
China is advanced. But not experienced in war as much as some of the coalition forces.
We call it a 5th column,, just as you say they are an enemy from within😮
Don't underestimate your enemy.
Sure, sure - keep that confidence coming. We’re just built different: you invest in words, we invest in work. Time will tell where that leads.
Taiwan isnt Ukraine...I dont think the US will ignore Taiwan...like the Philippines , Taiwan is an ally..a friend
China should think 10 x before duplicating the fatal mistake of russia.
What's russia's mistake? The russians have reached nearly all of their primary targets for this war
IF YOU ARE NOT ASIAN ..F7XXK OFF..ASIA DO NOT NEED YOUR WAR MONGERING IN ASIA...AND TAIWANESE WILL NOT FIGHT...😊
🤣🤣🤣 *USA, EU, NATO, G7, Aukus, 5 Eyes and QUAD 🤡 can't stop Small Chinese Huawei from Thriving* Needs to say more? 🤣🤣🤣
who committed the fatal mistake, Russia or Ukraine?
Russia won. Where is the fatal mistake? Russia proved that nuclear weapons negates all other considerations.
每個台灣人都得看（有台文字幕版更好）想＂一旦中共失去理智時，你我能幹什麼：至少，別慌忙電話朋友，不須急著道別佔用通訊頻道或用GPS上路去看熱鬧（留給國軍用），打好紧急黑熊包，裝滿水，危難來時就去避難處就急。對了，胡將軍請多聊聊平常生活點滴感覺滿好的
No. You need to start thinking like the Vietnamese , not the Chinese. Every man and woman needs to bear arms and defend yourselves. The rest of the world is coming to your aid, it would be nice for you to help.
What will be the consequence If China attack Taiwan? The exact consequence is Taiwan can raise its NATIONAL FLAG, a nation by fact and act. Why? No country would wage to its own place; the fact the China would want to take Taiwan is a fact the Taiwan is an independent nation by fact and act. There is no need to be discussing whose Taiwan is, because Taiwan by fact and act is a nation with its own government and Laws with its jurisdiction that China must respect. Congratulation Taiwan for courage!!! I salute you all!!!
So was Ukraine didn’t stop Putin.
Great analysis
As far as the Chinese hackers are concerned, perhaps the allied countries should switch to Macintosh! 😂🖥️😂
I was impressed by the skill in communicating answers to complex questions in such a concise and comprehensible way, well done
Taiwan is sovereign state it is only imperative to support Taiwan independence from china autocratic regime VIVA TAIWAN LONGLIVE❤❤❤
So many Chinese bots in the comments!
So many warmongers here .
@@cashcash5995yeah. They’re the Chinese bots 😂
Just shows how little vocabulary you have. bot.
They need to understand that China imports and exports too much. Their main buyer is the USA and they cannot replace that. The US buys 35% of all exports in the world. The minute you lose that consumer market, your economy is screwed and in China's case, eventually you starve. The US could blockade China's ability to feed its own people, 3000 miles away from China. They would have to come out and fight but they cannot sustain their navy past the first island chain.
US, Germany, France, Canada, Spain, Israel would help the aside from US allies in the Pacific.
This rhetoric is too crazy! Good luck with this illusion.
Taiwan is facing serious problem recruiting soldiers. Clinging hope on the US to come to the aid of Taiwan is a wishful dream. You just have to get your Taiwan president to declare independence to make it happen
This guy know his stuff and with swagger to boot.
Very good analysis
Sounds like this “expert” is just another loudmouth prick who thinks he’s got the future on speed dial 😂😂😂 I don't see China invading Taiwan and I don't think they will I just don't 😂😂😂 so this was stupid analysis to a so called expert, Gordon chang 2.0 😂😂
Those neighbors who come to Taiwan aid is thinking short term, but their proximity to China is long term, any neighbors countries aiding Taiwan is stupid.
Rubbish comments.
Maybe they are worse off if China takes Taiwan since China will have dominance over the South China Sea without Taiwan irritating them along the way
What?
You must be looking in a mirror.
As to whether China can conquer Taiwan, even the Taiwanese political leaders like Chen Tan Sun (Mark Chen), the former Secretary General of Taiwan National Security Council had admitted that the Chinese already have the capabilities to conquer Taiwan now !
"China vs USA - empires at war"
An idiot, to destroy Taiwan's bridges, power stations, etc. do we need sleeper agents? Do you know that the PLA can easily do it with their long range fire. Still dreaming, right?
Easily? Hahaha
you have supposed to say Easily to say but hard to do😂
@JaysonCastro-t7x there's the surprised element ace card one of the other will hold to decide this game😂
@@JaysonCastro-t7xthey are brainwashed slaves living in china.
Taiwan isn't that big just look at Russian strikes on Ukraine energy infrastructure
This man should go back to school.
Waht resilence ?? Over in 3 days.
True it will fail why? Chinese 2millions soldiers don't have experience in real war in this generation and chinese weapons never test in real war.
Chinese do test their weapons against live targets, such as old ships and successfully shot down their own satellite 20 years ago. You honestly think people do not do any test to see if their stuff works. They build a space station and landed on moon.
But the same goes to Taiwanese army
Inexperience is a factor only during the first few months of a war. Good doctrine and realistic training can do a lot to buffer it. It is not as big a factor in the case of Taiwan, where the decisive factor is Naval.
2million coward soldiers 😂😂
@jdmjr1130 What a stupid thing to say.
Where's the proof?
The formal government of China had to escape to Taiwan for the reds. So, formally China has no right to take back Taiwan. Meaning leave Taiwan in piece. The current governments since 1948, did not sit still. They developed their defence up till now. So, China, think first before you take any action against Taiwan. You can hurt yourselvs badly.
Soon the real chinese government will return to the mainland from Taiwan 🇹🇼
here the most dumb person on this planet .
Resillianche yang memberikan resistanching keamanan bersama pada zoon lions wilayah pertahanan bersama adalah untuk mengendalikan illegal trollicriminales traceris zoom lions secara kolaborasi. Potensi kedepannya untuk mengatasi populasi meningkatnya ilegal iads
this guy is a scammer. he was the sales representive of raython in Taiwan. Raython sold weapons to Taiwan with double price of other countries
@ Yan.........: Working for Raytheon in the US, says it all. Hey, Tony Hu,
" intuition " fee for this rubbish presentation from American M. Complex, or CIA, or NED ??
Conflict of interest
Demand is high in Taiwan for weapons and weapons are hard to build and take time to do so.
@James-e1h8l No, US usually sold taiwan outdated weapons. US govenment investigated raysheon and asked they refund around 2 billion dollars, which they overcharged. Tony Hu was the sale manager of this deal
That's an outright lie and you know it, wumao.
I am so curious how can an expert give such shameless comments without any shamelessness.
He is an idiotic or paid liar.
@@sunnytneoh3126'paid liar'
Are you looking into a mirror?
He's sharing like WhatsApp? One don't reveal top plan to anyone?
One thing for sure he is totally shameless to be called an expert 😂. He is more of paid liars to do their propaganda. 😂😂😂😂.
@@albertchu7926 cheap Chinese bot farmed comment
China have thousands of floating iron products ,very good in floating but maybe good also as artificial reefs.
I'm glad I was able to find this channel and am now subscribed 😊.
Superb factual analysis which can be easily digested by someone who knows more than anyone concerning Taiwan's defense responses and the enemies capabilities. Additionally, the gentleman's style is quite entertaining....love this show, love the channel ❤!
DPP funded channel doesn't know flag of ROC.😂😂😂😂 Pure propaganda channel.
The ROC and PRC are two separate entities.
PRC was formed in 1949. The ROC was officially recreated in 1951. October 1, 1949, at 3:00 pm in Tienanmen Square the formation of the Central People's Government under the leadership of the CCP, the government of the new state, was officially proclaimed. Mao declared victory to the people stating “The poor peasants have conquered the country; the poor peasants should now sit on the country.”
The PRC and a new nation was formed, The CCP created the constitution, and it did not even contain Taiwan. lol
In April 28, 1952 Article 10 of the Taipei Peace Treaty clearly declares the sovereignty of the ROC “nationals of the Republic of China shall be deemed to include all the inhabitants and former inhabitants of Taiwan (Formosa) and Penghu (the Pescadores).” Therefore the Taipei Peace Treaty declares the ROC to be All inhabitants of Taiwan but no mention of China or PRC.
@ResearchFirst-z7j lol, do you know what are you talking about? Do you know what is history and what is legacy?
BTW, pls check the constitution of PRC. Don't try to spread misleading information here.
Above that, does Taiwanese knows that ROC is "recreated" in 1952?
You refer to Taipei peace treaty, that is treaty between ROC and Japan. Doesn't define the territory of ROC. I don't know you lie on this. The territory definition is in ROC constitution, which includes both the Chinese mainland and Taiwan.
Please do more work, before you spread these nonsense words.
@@Qiushishuo Hang on Einstein, I just gave you evidence to prove that the ROC and PRC are two different entities.
There are no internationally recognised treaties, policies or UN resolutions that state that Taiwan is part of China,
So prove me wrong.
The Taipei Peace Treaty clearly declares the sovereignty of the ROC
“nationals of the Republic of China shall be deemed to include all the inhabitants and former inhabitants of Taiwan (Formosa) and Penghu (the Pescadores)."
And dont give me that constitution garbage.
When the ROC wrote their constitution in 1946 Taiwan belonged to Japan and therefore means nothing.
There are no internationally recognised treaties, policies or UN resolutions that state that Taiwan is part of China, and you cannot prove otherwise.
@ResearchFirst-z7j lol, you are so funny. As a defeated criminal in WWII, there is no right for Japan to hold Taiwan after Japan formally surrendered.
Your claim cannot even be supported by Japanese government. I don't why do you insist these lies.
@@ResearchFirst-z7j What he meant was that DPP(Democratic Progressive Party of Taiwan) is continuous putting lies on RUclips and other American media. DPP or the current ruling party of Taiwan is notorious for deceiving Taiwanese people. Yes, I am from Taiwan.
Taiwan is a cool country snd a brave neighbor.
under estimate china big mistake taiwan not a nation taiwan part of mother land stop talk tought taiwan is china
Well, you're right about one thing, Taiwan is the real China. Good job stating that loud and clear.
what? Nobody can understand your nationalistic gibberish
proc roc hongkong macau singapore chinatowns - one ancestor
Great communicator. The Best!
US should take China instead of Greenland.
ohh you are not telling the world community the truth.
The logic doesn’t make sense at all. 😂
The question is whether US has the incentive to defend Taiwan. The Ukraine war reveals the true Russia capabilities and if anything US is no longer worried about Russia anymore. China is the true strategic threat. Among various ways of preventing the threat, a war is an option, the earlier it breaks out the bigger advantage US has. China invading Taiwan provides the opportunity, isn’t it?
Exactly
This guy is not an expert he's a plant
A vegetable plant.
No. He’s a clown.
OKay bot.
27 years as US Air Force officer including Missile combat Crew Commander, HQ Pacific Air Forces, and Pacific Area War Planner. 7 Years as US Dept of Defense Senior Official including as Senior Director for China/Taiwan/Mongolia in the Office of the Secretary of Defense, Pentagon and Dep Chief of Security Assistance Office in Taiwan.
USA HAS 700 ARMY BASES AROUND THE GLOBE IN 80 COUNTERIES
Useless to have so many army bases. USA forever never had war with china just to protect Taiwan.
So you think Taiwan wins.
It is a lose lose for Taiwan and China better to get along
The BIBLE have emphasized the importance of alliance which china practically lacks
china don't need alliance/gang or god
The total value of exports to China reaching approximately $101 billion in 2023; making China the largest export destination for Taiwan despite a slight decrease in recent years.
So just a ban on all Taiwan imports would do, no boots on ground needed.
Dominant product:
Integrated circuits (ICs) are the main export from Taiwan to China, with a significant portion coming from companies like TSMC (Taiwan Semiconductor Manufacturing Company).
Decreasing trend:
While still substantial, Taiwan's exports to China have been declining slightly in recent years due to factors like geopolitical tensions and a shift towards diversifying export markets.
Other major exports:
Aside from ICs, Taiwan also exports broadcasting equipment and office machine parts to China.
Drones dominate today’s battlefield. Taiwan needs to invest heavily in drone technology now
@@charleslloyd7762 They gave 800 big drones to Ukraine last year I believe
@ROC Gov't: Technically, if done properly, the ROC can win against the PRC militarily, just as did Sparta and it's allies against the Persians. Many people do not know that.
Personally, I hope the Chinese people can coexist peacefully, and not fight each other, but that is up to the Chinese (PRC gov't/ROC gov't) on both sides of the TaiWan/China Strait. Most of the wars China has fought in have been civil wars throughout the ages, including the ongoing civil war between the ROC and PRC entities... Very unfortunate.
I hope you are right and being has China up to now has never invaded another country with planes and tanks. There is hope And hope that Taiwan wont be the first.But realistcally what value is a small island such as Taiwan to PRC ?any way Even with American help they would lose, as it is far away from the US.And aircraft carriers are so WW2. Ukraine is a typical example It was suicide to take on Russia on her own door step Britain and the Falklands was the exception But i dont think Argentina was enthusiastic for the Malvinas and never planned it very well
Taiwan should enlist Filipino fighters.. 😁
Taiwan needs to ASAP get serious about a robust citizen defense force, 15 million AKs', yes, THAT MANY!, and plenty ammo ... but I doubt they will..SAD!
Thanks for your down to earth expert insights Tony! 臺灣加油👍👍👍
📙3. THE GOSPEL OF THE WORD OF ALMIGHTY GOD "the last age is the Age of Kingdom or Word brought by Christ to purify man"
Only Those Who Have Experienced God's Work Truly Believe in God
Almighty God Says
If PEOPLE STAY in the AGE of GRACE, THEN they will NEVER be FREE from their EVIL DISPOSITIONS, much less KNOW the NATURAL DISPOSITIONS of GOD. IF PEOPLE always LIVE in the AFFORDABILITY of GRACE but DO NOT HAVE the WAY of LIFE that ALLOWS them to KNOW GOD and GIVE--SATISFACTION to GOD, then they will NEVER TRULY OBTAIN Him EVEN THOUGH they BELIEVE in Him. WHAT a pitiful form of BELIEF that is. When you FINISH READING this BOOK, when you EXPERIENCE every STEP of the WORK of GOD INCARNATION in the AGE of the KINGDOM, you will FEEL that the HOPE of many PEOPLE has FINALLY BEEN FULFILLED. 🌷🙏🔴
You will FEEL that NOW you have TRULY SEEN GOD face to face; NOW you have STANDED on GOD'S FACE, HEARD GOD'S PERSONAL SPEECH, APPRECIATED the WISDOM of GOD'S WORK and TRULY FELT how TRUE and POWERFUL GOD is. You will FEEL that you have ACHIEVED MANY THINGS that PEOPLE in the PAST TIMES HAVE NEVER SEEN or CLAIMED. 🌷🙏🌷🙏
At this TIME, you will CLEARLY SEE WHAT BELIEVING in GOD, and WHAT FOLLOWING the HEART of GOD. 🌷🙏🔥
PLEASE NOTE, IF YOU HOLD on to the VIEWS of the PAST, and WILL NOT ACCEPT or REJECT the TRUTH of the SECOND INCARNATION--MAN of GOD, THEN you WILL REMAIN TONGUELESS and NOTHING ACQUIRED, and in the END--LASTLY WILL SIN of DEFENDING GOD. Those who FOLLOW the TRUTH and SUBMIT to the WORK of GOD WILL COME UNDER the NAME of the SECOND INCARNATION--MAN GOD---the POWERFUL--over--ALL. 🙏🌷
They WILL RECEIVE PERSONAL GUIDANCE from GOD, and WILL ACHIEVE greater and HIGHER TRUTH and will RECEIVE TRUE human LIFE. 🙏
They WILL SEE a VISION that PEOPLE HAVE NEVER SEEN BEFORE: "And I turned to see a voice speaking unto Me. And when I turned I saw seven golden candlesticks: And in the midst of the candlesticks there was one like a son of man, clothed with a garment down to the feet, and having his breast girded with a golden girdle. And his head and his hair were white like wool, like snow; and his eyes were like a flame of fire; And his feet were like polished brass, as refined in an iron furnace; and his voice was likesplash a lot of water. And in his right hand were seven stars: and out of his mouth went a sharp two-edged sword: and his face was like the sun shining brightly." (Revelation 1:12-16). 🔥🙏
This VISION is the EXPRESSION of GOD'S WHOLE DISPOSITION, and such an EXPRESSION of His entire disposition is also an EXPRESSION of GOD'S WORK when He became MAN during this TIME. In the flood of punishments and judgments, the SON of MAN appreciates His NATURAL DISPOSITION by UTTERING WORDS, allowing all who receive His PUNISHMENT and JUDGMENT to SEE the TRUE FACE of the SON of MAN, a FACE already FAITHFUL DESCRIPTION of the face of the SON of MAN as SEEN by JOHN.🔥
(Of course, all of this will not be seen by those who do not accept God's work in the Age of Kingdom.) The TRUE FACE of the CANNOT be FULLY expressed CLEARLY USING MAN'S WORDS, and thus GOD USES the REVEALING of His NATUREDISPOSITION to SHOW His TRUE FACE to PEOPLE. Which means that EVERYONE WHO EXPERIENCES the NATURAL DISPOSITION of the SON of MAN has SEEN the REAL FACE of the SON of MAN, because GOD is too GREAT and CANNOT be COMPLETELY EXPRESSED CLEARLY USING human words. 🔴
Once man has experienced every step of God's work in the AGE OF THE KINGDOM, then he will KNOW the TRUE MEANING of JOHN'S words when he SPOKE OF THE SON OF MAN IN THE MIDST of the candlesticks: "And his head and his hair are white aswool white as snow; and his eyes were like a flame of fire; And his feet were like polished brass, as refined in an iron furnace; and his voice is like the rushing of many waters. And in his right hand are seven stars: and out of his mouth goeth a sharp two-edged sword: and his face is like the sun shining brightly." 🔥🙏🔥
AT THAT TIME, YOU WILL KNOW UNMIXED- This COMMON FLESH will be doubted SPEAKING so MANY WORDS is REALLY the SECOND INCARNATION--the MAN of GOD.🙏
And you will REALLY FEEL HOW BLESSED you are, and FEEL that YOURSELF is the BLESSED.🌷
Won't you be READY to RECEIVE this GRACE?
The FIRST PART of this BOOK is the WORDS of the SPIRIT to the CHURCHES. 🙏
These WORDS REPRESENT the TRANSITION from the END of the AGE of GRACE to the BEGINNING of the KINGDOM AGE, and these are the PUBLIC WITNESSES of the SPIRIT to the CHURCHES concerning the SON OF MAN. 🙏🔴
These are also the FULFILLMENTS of the WORDS in the BOOK of REVELATION that "He who has an ear, let him listen to what the Spirit says to the churches." This is the WORK GOD BEGAN in the KINGDOM AGE. The SECOND PART of this BOOK is the PERSONAL WORDS SPOKE by the SON of MAN after He OFFICIALLY REVEALED Himself.🙏
It contains a rich content of many TYPES of UTTERANCES and WORDS such as PROPHECY, the REVELATION of MYSTERIES, and the WAY OF LIFE. There are PROPHECIES for the FUTURE of the KINGDOM, REVELATIONS of the MYSTERIES of GOD'S GOVERNMENT PLAN, ANALYSIS of HUMAN NATURE, SERMONS and WARNINGS, STRICT JUDGMENTS, SINCERE words of COMFORT, CONVERSATIONS on LIFE, ADMISSION CONVERSATION, and more. 🔴🙏
In other words, what God has, what He is, and GOD'S DISPOSITION are ALL SHOWN in His ACTIONS and WORDS. of COURSE, when GOD BECAME FLESH at this TIME, His JOB was to DECLARE His DISPOSITION, MAINLY through PUNISHMENT and JUDGMENT. Using this as a FOUNDATION, He BRINGS MORE TRUTH to MAN, shows more methods of practice, and thus ACHIEVES His PURPOSE of SUBJECTING man and SAVING MAN from His EVIL DISPOSITION. This is what is BEHIND God's WORK in the Kingdom Age. 🙏🔴
Do you WANT to ENTER the NEW AGE? Do YOU WANT to REMOVE BAD DISPOSITIONS from YOURSELF? Do you want to ATTAIN a HIGHER REALITY? Do YOU WANT to SEE the REAL FACE of thr SON of MAN? Do YOU WANT to LIVE a LIFE of USEFULNESS? Do0 YOU WANT to be MADE PERFECT by GOD? If so, HOW will you WELCOME JESUS' RETURN? 🙏
⬇️
The recorded prophecy is below!
⬇️
The fulfillment of Juan's VISION
(Rev. 1:12-16 "A Vision of Christ")
"And I turned to see a voice speaking unto Me. And when I turned I saw seven golden candlesticks: And in the midst of the candlesticks there was one like a son of man, clothed with a garment down to the feet, and having his breast girded with a golden girdle. And his head and his hair were white like wool, like snow; and his eyes were like a flame of fire; And his feet were like polished brass, as refined in an iron furnace; and his voice was likesplash a lot of water. And in his right hand were seven stars: and out of his mouth went a sharp two-edged sword: and his face was like the sun shining brightly." (Rev. 1:12-16).
⬇️
↪️(Note:
Almighty God said, They WILL SEE a VISION that PEOPLE HAVE NEVER SEEN BEFORE: "And I turned to see a voice speaking unto Me. And when I turned I saw seven golden candlesticks: And in the midst of the candlesticks there was one like a son of man, clothed with a garment down to the feet, and having his breast girded with a golden girdle. And his head and his hair were white like wool, like snow; and his eyes were like a flame of fire; And his feet were like polished brass, as refined in an iron furnace; and his voice was likesplash a lot of water. And in his right hand were seven stars: and out of his mouth went a sharp two-edged sword: and his face was like the sun shining brightly." (Revelation 1:12-16). This VISION is the EXPRESSION of GOD'S WHOLE DISPOSITION, and such an EXPRESSION of His entire disposition is also an EXPRESSION of GOD'S WORK when He became MAN during this TIME.)
⬇️
(Rev. 2:7,11,27,29, and 3:6,13 The Letter to the Churches)
"He who has an ear, let him listen to what the Spirit says to the churches."
⬇️
↪️(Note: Almighty God said, These are also the FULFILLMENTS of the WORDS in the BOOK of REVELATION that "He who has an..
I like this guy! 🇬🇧 ❤ 🇹🇼
1k pinoy vs 40k gungung flu. Battle of yuldong
Noon iyon. Iba na ngayon.
China would find it very difficult if they invade Taiwan, because they expect an invasion and are very ready to defend themselves
This commentator has a green mouth, a green heart, a green brain, and everything in him is green, just like the green metal cabinet beside him, actually not fresh green but shitty green. Hahaha.
Yes, you have a red and communist mouth. Loser
Yea your mom's b is green
probably wears a green hat to sleep
China under the CCP mismanagement of it's economy is one for Taiwan's best attributes for it's defense. The real estate collapse las an empty apartment for every person, man woman and child in that country. All the banks are insolvent. Every "stimulus" by the CCP is met by a brief stock market rally followed by and further decline deeper that before. The economy is collapsing. Youth unemployment is at least 59%. The attitude of hopelessness among the youth is charactered by the phrase of ;lie flat' do as little as possible to 'let it die'.
I like the way he presented it in a calm manner, very clear and straight to the point.
“The collation force that might assist Taiwan” Right, they will definitely come 🤣
Very good analysis
Why would China make such a sick effort just for a frivolous Taiwan? What would they do with it? Their manufacturing sector is in trouble, and they logically should be thinking more about that…
Support taiwan Freedom
why
God bless tiwan and protect their land and stay strong
Tony, thanks for sharing your expertise.
Exactly, Europe was talking about politics but did little to help Ukraine over time.
Time is a advantage to a big aggressor.
Massively building quality sea and air drones is the cheapest option.
Harpoons and Patriots are a better bet but are more costly
The world should defend Taiwan in the bame of freedom and to live free
The question should be, how many soldiers would die within the coast of Taiwanese if china ask itself?
You should write in Chinese so your comments can be understood.
If the premise that allies of Taiwan will join the war is true, then he is correct
I’m laughing when I hear how the way he glorified Taiwan’s capability , he’s a joke 😂😂😂
Just because you’re weak doesn’t mean others with strengths are a joke. Loser mentality
A joke? You poor brainwashed slave of china?
you're offended. that's cute
@@cfoldesh Not invasion, just recovering lost territory, the taiwanese and green birds can go live in trump's house or in
Belize
Guatemala
Haiti
Marshall Islands
Palau
Paraguay
Saint Kitts and Nevis
Saint Lucia
Saint Vincent and the Grenadines
Eswatini
Tuvalu
Vatican City
@@AnthonyHudsonAlessandro wait.... which side are you on? How does trump fit into this equation? He would happily feed Taiwan to China.
Great show..!
Hello Taiwan 🇹🇼 is a Sovereign Country have a nice day 🙂
DPP funded channel doesn't know flag of ROC.😂😂😂😂 Pure propaganda channel.
@@Qiushishuo Taiwan was not even added to the PRC constitution until 1978?
The 1978 PRC Constitution was the first Constitution in the PRC to touch explicitly on the political status of Taiwan. It said that "Taiwan is part of China" and said that the PRC "must liberate Taiwan, and finish the great task of reunifying the motherland".
However, in 1979, the PRC dropped the liberation stance and opted for peaceful reunification instead.
The 1982 Constitution mentioned that "Taiwan is a sacred part of the territory of the People's Republic of China" instead of just "China".
The fact is the war was never over Taiwan and during the civil war the island legally belonged to Japan not China.
Once Mao died the PRC constitution was amended to state that Taiwan was part of China,
23 million vs 1.4billion. sure😂
If so, tell the Taiwanese Goverment to declare Independence tomorrow, otherwise all you are saying is nonsense. Btw, life must be difficult not being a US defense officer anymore, coming here talking nonsnese getting few extra bucks 😂
Irrespective of whether Taiwan is considered a country or not does not automatically cede the sovereignty to China.
The fact is that there are no internationally recognized treaties, policies or UN resolutions that state that Taiwan is part of China. In fact, Taiwan was not even included into the PRC constitution until 1978.
@@ResearchFirst-z7j Taiwan is a part of China for a lot of reasons, but I'll give you 3. Number 1: Taiwan and Mainland China are the Inheritance of Qing Dynasty, whether Communists or Non-communists run Mainland China and Taiwan, it's a part of China(whether it's communist or not). Number 2: Taiwan is not a name of the country, but a name of the place. Republic of China is the name of Taiwan, and there is the word "China" in it. So it's part of China, or it's China. The problem of Taiwan and Mainland China is not about whether Taiwan is a part of China( because it is), but rather who runs the whole China(Mainland China + Taiwan). The Republic of China lost in the Civil War, they should merge with Mainland China(ruled by the Communists). Number 3: People who are living in Taiwan all come from Mainland China, and they are about 20 millions of them, then WTH the land of All Chinese should be decided by only 20 millions Chinese people in Taiwan but not 1.4 billion Chinese in Mainland China? Taiwan or Mainland China are the lands of current Chinese's ancestors and all Chinese(regardless they are living in Mainland China, Hong Kong, Macau, Taiwan) should have the say and right to say in it, not just a few 20 millions people in Taiwan.
No internally treaties recognize Taiwan is a part of China? Do Chinese people in Mainland China need a treaty to claim their homeland of their ancestors? You do know International Treaties are for the benefits of the Winners of WW2, right? And since China was not USA, USSR, Britan, and they were conquered by the Imperial Japanese, who cares about their territorial integrity? But that does not mean Taiwan is not them. The problem with Taiwan nowadays is Taiwanese Politicians trying to get votes by creating dramas to push normal citizens to unnecessary wars with their blood brothers and sisters. That's all. It's not about democracy, just pure greed of power by the politicians.
@@brianawhite1796 That is a lovely Anglo Saxon name Brian White. How funny. Lol
The fact is that there are no internationally recognized treaties, policies or UN resolutions that state that Taiwan is part of China and you are going to have to try much harder to prove otherwise. ha ha ha
1: You claim that China is the inheritance of the Manchurian Qing Dynasty who were not even Chinese. Lol What a joke.
Please show me where the Manchurians transferred their conquered lands to the PRC. Prove it
2: In terms of Taiwan, the Manchurians never conquered Taiwan and only loosely controlled less than 20% of Taiwan. therefore there was nothing to inherit. LOL
The Qing annexed Taiwan in 1683 but only controlled the western plains, with their authority limited to the “Niu line,” a boundary separating the lowlands from the mountainous interior. Beyond this line, Indigenous peoples maintained control over most of the island. While the Qing made small expansions beyond the Niu line, their reach remained minimal. Han and Hakka settlers frequently clashed over land and resources, fueled by rivalries from Fujian. Limited resources and weak administration further reduced Qing control.
Japan was the first country to subdue the Taiwanese aboriginals and seize control of Taiwan.
Your funny. lol
3: The Republic of China is not China and has not been since 1971.
The ROC and PRC are two separate entities.
PRC was formed in 1949. The ROC was officially recreated in 1951. October 1, 1949, at 3:00 pm in Tienanmen Square the formation of the Central People's Government under the leadership of the CCP, the government of the new state, was officially proclaimed. Mao declared victory to the people stating “The poor peasants have conquered the country; the poor peasants should now sit on the country.”
The PRC and a new nation was formed, The CCP created the constitution, and it did not even contain Taiwan. lol
In April 28, 1952 Article 10 of the Taipei Peace Treaty clearly declares the sovereignty of the ROC “nationals of the Republic of China shall be deemed to include all the inhabitants and former inhabitants of Taiwan (Formosa) and Penghu (the Pescadores).” Therefore the Taipei Peace Treaty declares the ROC to be All inhabitants of Taiwan but no mention of China or PRC.
Tell me why there is a country called Guinea, another called Papua New Guinea, another called Guinea Bissau and another called Equatorial Guinea????? Are they all the same country??
I can't stop laughing. lol
4: In terms of the civil war. During the civil war Taiwan was part of Japan. The civil war was never over Taiwan.
In fact, Taiwan was not even added to the PRC constitution until 1978? This is hilarious.
The 1978 PRC Constitution was the first Constitution in the PRC to touch explicitly on the political status of Taiwan. It said that "Taiwan is part of China" and said that the PRC "must liberate Taiwan, and finish the great task of reunifying the motherland".
However, in 1979, the PRC dropped the liberation stance and opted for peaceful reunification instead.
The 1982 Constitution mentioned that "Taiwan is a sacred part of the territory of the People's Republic of China" instead of just "China".
The fact is the war was never over Taiwan and during the civil war the island legally belonged to Japan not China.
Once Mao died the PRC constitution was amended to state that Taiwan was part of China,
Sorry I am still laughing. lol
5: Yes, the PRC will need a treaty to claim Taiwan as it has never been controlled by the PRC or China.
As I told you there are no internationally recognized treaties, policies, agreements or UN resolutions that declare that Taiwan is part of China and you cannot prove otherwise. Lol
When Japan relinquished its sovereignty of Taiwan with The Treaty of San Francisco after the ROC invaded the Japanese island, China was not even invited. The treaty was signed by 49 nations including the Soviet Union but the CCP were NOT present.
I am crying with laughter.
6: Yes, I agree with you, its ALL about greed and power of the CCP.
Historically the CCP recognized Formosan independence. In 1936, when the Republic of China (ROC) was China’s government and Taiwan (Formosa) was a Japanese colony, Chairman Mao Zedong offered support to Korea and Formosa if their peoples wished to gain independence from Japan. Mao’s internationalist position suggested that 1) both Korea and Formosa have a right to independence, and 2) this is based on the right to self-determination. Mao did not claim that Taiwan has been an integral part of China for centuries, as insisted by the Chinese government today. Interview with Mao in 1936
An interview sourced from the Marxist Archive demonstrates this.
Interviewer EDGAR SNOW: “Is it the immediate task of the Chinese people to regain all the territories lost to Japan, or only to drive Japan from North China, and all Chinese territory above the Great Wall? “
MAO: “It is the immediate task of China to regain all our lost territories, not merely to defend our sovereignty below the Great Wall. This means that Manchuria must be regained. We do not, however, include Korea, formerly a Chinese colony, but when we have re-established the independence of the lost territories of China, and if the Koreans wish to break away from the chains of Japanese imperialism, we will extend them our enthusiastic help in their struggle for independence. The same thing applies to Formosa.”
Source: Marxists Internet Archive
You are so funny and thank you for the laughter.
if you want to learn more truths about Taiwan please feel free to let me know. lol
Have a great day.
I enjoyed your video thankyou. The facts, the threats, the strengths, the different scenarios were interesting. 🇦🇺
We have a phrase in Australia: 'Tell him he's dreamin'.
So Taiwan can get a good lawyer. Job done
Australia should mind its own business and keep out of the area, God knows why we’re sending naval vessels into Taiwan straits , and south China Sea. we should mind our own business.
great show